Tell Me What You Did by Carter Wilson (Poisoned Pen Press)

"Tell Me What You Did" is a gripping narrative that explores the intricate layers of confession, morality, and the enduring impact of past actions. At the center of this story is Poe Webb, a podcast host who invites guests to anonymously share their wrongdoings. While she immerses herself in the shadows of others' secrets, Poe carries a haunting truth of her own: she killed her mother’s murderer, believing him to be dead until a man claiming to be that very person appears on her show. This unexpected encounter forces her to confront her buried past.

The plot unfolds through Poe's podcast, where the anonymity provided to guests allows them to candidly discuss their darkest deeds. This creates an engaging dynamic, drawing listeners into the confessions while Poe struggles to maintain emotional distance from the crimes being revealed. However, when the mysterious man claims to be her mother’s killer, her life spirals into chaos, compelling her to reevaluate her own actions and the moral complexities intertwined with them.

Poe Webb is portrayed as a multifaceted protagonist and a skilled podcast host who uses her platform to unveil the secrets of others while grappling with her own guilt over her mother’s murder. The enigmatic man serves as both an antagonist and a catalyst for her journey, challenging her to reflect on her past decisions and the ethical boundaries she has crossed.

Carter Wilson’s writing style is crisp and engaging, characterized by skillful pacing and sharp prose that draw readers into the depths of his characters’ psyches. He effectively builds tension and suspense throughout the narrative, creating a story that captivates from beginning to end.

Positioned within the psychological thriller genre, "Tell Me What You Did" masterfully blends elements of mystery and suspense while delving into universal themes such as revenge, morality, and the complexities of human nature. The novel raises thought-provoking questions about confession and whether one can truly escape their past.

A significant theme revolves around justice and the nature of good versus evil. Are those who commit murder always villains? Is it possible for someone to move beyond their previous actions? These inquiries resonate with contemporary discussions surrounding crime, punishment, and societal judgment.

In summary, "Tell Me What You Did" presents a riveting and thought-provoking reading experience that entertains and encourages readers to reflect on deeper moral questions regarding guilt, redemption, and the consequences of our choices. The narrative's brisk pace and engaging style make it accessible to a broad audience, including those who may not typically consider themselves avid readers. While some might find the characters lacking in emotional depth or the plot twists somewhat predictable, the novel remains a compelling exploration of the darker facets of human nature.

3/5